1. - Bayonetta
2. - Arkham Series (I know, you said no Batman, and while there have been "Batman" games before, the "Arkham" series IMO stands on its own as an IP)
3. - Uncharted
4. - Bioshock (yeah, I know, System Shock could technically disqualify this, but I feel compelled to rank it none the less)
5. - Mod Nation Racers