Selling gaming accessories. Click
Most CRT's during the first decade of this century were manufactured with component inputs for a reason (Even many small budget sets included a set of component inputs). It gives a definite quality boost despite still being standard definition. I most certainly notice a huge boost in picture quality on my PS2, GCN, Xbox, Wii, and a old 360 I have hooked up to my standard definition Trinitron for the occasional classic game when using component cables. No midding involved and they're all consoles best enjoyed on a nice CRT rather than hooking them up to a modern DLP/Plasma/LCD HDTV (Except the 360, of course).
The benefits of component video don't start and end with being able to support progessive scan or even HD. They offer a noticeable boost in quality for similar reasons why an image will look nicer going from RF to composite cables. It's very much worthwhile when it's an option for standard definition consoles hooked up to a nice CRT.
Last edited by Leo_A; 06-04-2012 at 10:46 PM.
Threre's a much bigger jump in quality going from composite to s-video than there is going from s-video to component.
S-video and component use the exact same luma channel. Component produces better colour, but as far as image sharpness goes, they're the same.
Some folks don't seem to understand that it's not about resolution with these classic systems, but rather clarity and color. Nobody's trying to make their TurboGrafx put out a 1080P image or magically transform their SD CRT into something else.
I'd rather stick with RF or composite outputs on my old systems to avoid ruining any transparency or dithering effects.
It's primarily found on Genesis due to limited color palette. Even then varies by title.
The majority of games benefit more from a sharper cleaner overall image, than reduced dithering on objects or effects. Using RF or composite means any graphics NOT dithered will suffer.
Most games didn't dither enough of the screen area for that wider quality loss to be worth it.
Okay guys, I would never argue that a newer system is not better via component than s-video or composite. I have an old XBOX, going from S-video to component doesn't make a big difference, but going from s-video on a CRT to component on an LCD HD sure does!
My position was related to older systems that didn't output more than S-video without modification. My point was that on either an old standard CRT, or a new HDTV, the difference between S-Video and Composite isn't noticeable. I have no problem if you want to spend the money to upgrade to component/RGB if the system could do it, but I do not see the difference. Once the game is moving, you will not notice. I've see the still image comparisons, and sure the S-video or component looks better, but when you play the game, you will not notice. I never do. Where you will notice is lesser quality audio, or a fuzzy connection brought on by RF, not to mention the lack of clarity on an SD TV vs. an HD TV, even for SD inputs.
I switched to S-Video with the Gamecube and noticed an improvment in graphics quality when playing F-Zero. Not its not as drastic as SD to HD, but everything was brighter and lines were sharper. Also a lot easier to see text.
"Oh my lord it's nutty, yup!"
To some extent it's less noticeable in motion. Video interference can also be. I don't see those Master System / Genesis vertical RGB bars as much when moving, or depending on the graphics shown.
For all of back in the day that used the RF; what channel would you play on? I along with the majoirty of my friends always switched to Channel 3, however I had a few friends that used channel 4; I considered these people low brow and they contributed nothing to society. Did the first NES systems even have the option to connect componenets to the TV from the system, i always had to fiddle with the RF.
Last edited by Flam; 06-12-2012 at 11:02 PM.
I was quite happy that the original PSX had actual A/V ports on it, though they took them off a revision or two in. Jerks. I hear the original Japanese model even had a built in S-Video port.
I LOVED my TG16! Keith Courage was/is one of my fav pack-in games ever! Probably only 2nd to SMW. It was 2 years before I got a Turbo Tap, and a 2-player game to go along with it. Could've been a completely different scene had NEC managed to stay in the game. There were some seriously solid titles for that console that time, for the most part, has pretty much wiped from memory.