PDA

View Full Version : How are your local collectible toy stores holding up in the current recession?


Pantechnicon
03-15-2009, 06:43 AM
The title of the thread is self-explanatory: How are your locally owned shops that specialize in collectible toys/comics/RPG & Wargames, or any combination thereof, faring in the current economic downturn? I'd like to hear about locally owned stores, not Borders, Gamestops, etc., and for that matter not necessarily video game stores unless that's secondary to some other merchandise like, say, comics.

Of the six or seven stores in Albuquerque I can think of off the top of my head, most of them are either in trouble or dead already, and these states have only come into being since the end of Christmas:

- Planet X: the newest one I can think of, sold sci-fi toys, original GI Joe, Transformers, etc. opened and closed within one year.

- Addicted To Comics and Games: Open since 1992. Comics, toys, videogames. The owner has been holding a 25% off everything sale for the last 3 weeks.

- Tall Tales Comics: Open at least as long as Addicted To Comics. Sells comics, toys, and everything you can think of related to Warhammer. I was just there today and everything is marked at 40% off. This actually puts some of their newer NIB stuff (like Iron Man movie figures) below what you'd pay for it at somewhere like Target.

- Xeno: Open since 2006. Sold collectible toys, all NIB, in a local mall. Recently moved out of the mall, more or less across the street, and shut their doors three months later.

- Chibi Metropolis: Open since 2006. Collectible toys, anime/manga. Operates in another mall across town from me. Last time I looked (Dec 2008) they were still open but had moved into smaller digs in the mall, which tells me they weren't making their rent in their old location. I wouldn't be surprised if they folded post-Christmas.

- Noble Collectibles: Open since 1995. Comics, video games, toys, sports cards. They have two stores, neither of which seem to be in trouble; no deep discounts or anything. However, one of these stores I know from semi-regular visits is quite a tomb inside. Inventory barely moved for the last six months. I also know that the owner of these two stores has a new, very successful business venture underway in selling bubble tea (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bubble_tea), so for all I know the Noble stores are operating at a loss and merely being kept afloat by the bubble tea profits.

- Astro Zombies: Open since 2001. Sells comics, action figures and Japanese import toys. No discernible problems yet.


That's my local rundown. Part of me rejoices at this because some of these stores price their wares in the highest echelons of Ebay-style wishful thinking, so a bit of an attitude adjustment is in order. On the other hand it worries me (as a late-30's geek who still likes a lot of these things) to see the long-term survival of these types of stores threatened by an economy where The Fun can no longer be afforded as such.

Getting sleepy...but feel free to add your own lists. Let's see if there's a trend afoot.

Gunface
03-15-2009, 08:15 AM
You seem to have some decent activity in the area with all those stores. Too bad things aren't looking so good for them. But I agree, it's incredibly irritating to see some of those "wishful thinking" prices. There's a game shop nearby with a CIB Final Fight Guy (SNES) for $500. I realize having the box for that game is rare, but who in Salem, MA is going to buy that?

We have a shop in town called Comically Speaking that fits your "tomb" description. No joke, they have some inventory that has to have been there since the mid-90's. They recently moved to a bigger location across the street (recently being in the last 5 years) but I haven't been in for a while.

There was a shop called Webhead nearby that may have closed recently. You have to give these guys credit, having a comic/toy shop is a risky business.

boatofcar
03-15-2009, 11:12 AM
I read an article in a recent issue of MAKE magazine that said hobby stores in general were doing quite well in the recession, though those types of stores are a bit different than stores that sell only collectibles.

scooterb23
03-17-2009, 08:15 AM
My area isn't exactly a hotbed for collectible toy stores. We have a small comic shop in town that seems to be chugging along.

In the next largest town, their last comic book store just closed, and the RC plane / car store would shut down if they didn't own the building.

The next biggest town...one shop, doing fine, he's always been very adaptable though. And great at spotting when trends are dying out, so he never gets stuck with a bunch of fad crap he'll never sell.

Columbus has a ton of stores, and they all seem to be hanging in there at least. I haven't seen any of them moving towards closing, at least yet.

mnbren05
03-17-2009, 05:37 PM
Had one local store called Comics 2 Cards. They sold comics, cards, collectibles, and some sports jereseys. THey had been open for 5-6 years and recently closed up. Ran into a worker there that said it was a combination of bad economy/sickness in the family. A real shame, they had some good stuff.

aaron7
04-24-2009, 04:02 PM
KB Toys was all that was near me and as we all know; they went out of business.

Pantechnicon
04-24-2009, 04:33 PM
KB Toys was all that was near me and as we all know; they went out of business.

Yeah, it was sad to see them go. I started this thread, though, with the specific question of how locally owned stores were doing. If a monolithic mainstream toy shop like Kaybee can't keep its doors open, how are places dealing with high-end or import stuff going to fare?

If anyone's interested in a local update, the following changes have happened since I started the thread:

- Astro Zombies, whom I said was in "no discernible trouble", has actually moved into a better larger location. That was surprising. They must be doing something right.

- Tall Tales Comics has ended its 40% sale and gone back to regular pricing. Whatever they were trying to do worked, I guess.

- Addicted To Comics and Games has deepened their 25% off sale to 40%. Not good. But on the other hand I always thought this was the most overpriced store in town. Maybe I'd better get over there before they shutter up for good and get that Shogun Gaiking (http://www.flickr.com/photos/vintagehalloweencollector/400774452/) I've had my eye on for a couple of years now.

Gameboy Color
04-26-2009, 02:45 AM
Off the top of my head:

Al's Comics - Seem to be doing slightly better than in years past.
Tao Toys - Ok. I've been told that the owner has been seeing some hard times and it's effecting the business.
Comic Grapevine - Has been doing steadily better and better over the last few years.

Diosoth
04-27-2009, 12:15 AM
Walmart is all I have. They rarely restock anything, probably to cut down on doing work.

KB is closed. But the last thing I bought there was Rouge the Bat from the Sonic X toy line in early 2008. I generally avoided them. Most stuff that other stores carried had an average of a 25% cost markup. They also stocked up heavily on the Sonic X space suit wave and 2000 Chris Thorndyke figures, so I was lucky to buy the one Rouge I saw.

The comic store only stocks DC Direct now, none of their stuff I ever want.

Besides, I usually find it cheaper to order online. You can yell at me for not supporitng local business, but money talks and I stretch my budget. If a store in my area has to close because their prices are higher, too bad. A store has no expectation for people to want to pay more for the same goods.

Joe West
04-27-2009, 04:09 AM
the Ma & Pa stores are slowly closing.........in my area, just a few people trying too setup
at flea-markets

slapdash
04-27-2009, 04:11 AM
I wouldn't have thought there was anything like this near me, but I recently found out that Monster Island Toys bought a stripmall storefront by me (I can't recall if they were only doing web sales before, or if they had a place in Chicago but moved to be closer to their clientele) and seem to be doing okay (sale on at the moment), and Japanese Toys & Gifts has been here for a while, though they only really to eBay sales, or maybe open for "members", but generally have a storefront that is never actually open to the public; weird, but evidently doing okay. This is Arlington Heights IL.

jb143
04-27-2009, 07:25 PM
I've been meaning to go to the local toy store here for years but never have. I certainly hope it's doing well. The guy that owns it is really nice and they cary stuff you can't get at most other stores. He introduced us to those 20Q games a few years before they hit other stores.

Diosoth
04-29-2009, 07:56 PM
I wouldn't have thought there was anything like this near me, but I recently found out that Monster Island Toys bought a stripmall storefront by me (I can't recall if they were only doing web sales before, or if they had a place in Chicago but moved to be closer to their clientele) and seem to be doing okay (sale on at the moment), and Japanese Toys & Gifts has been here for a while, though they only really to eBay sales, or maybe open for "members", but generally have a storefront that is never actually open to the public; weird, but evidently doing okay. This is Arlington Heights IL.

So... they run an actual store but don't let people in. I fail to see the reasoning. Sounds like the owner is just being a dick. For members only? So I have to pay a fee to step foot in? Then someone like that doesn't deserve to stay in business.

It's not even comparable to Sam's Club, since they have Walmart as a normal store.

tofu
04-29-2009, 08:37 PM
Business in my area is so bad that malls, stripmalls and even swap meets are offering six months free rent with nothing more than a security deposit.

So many of the smaller flea market vendors are opening up storefronts but even they're doing so badly it's a waste of time.

slapdash
05-05-2009, 05:34 AM
@Diosoth: I don't get it either... I'm not sure he actually charges for memberships or not. I bought something off him on eBay, and asked if I could pick it up. He agreed, and let me in the store. He mentioned something about not liking it when people come in and paw through everything but don't buy. I sort of understand that, but still... His way seems odd. But when he knew I was buying SOMETHING, he wasn't unfriendly at all. So odd, but... not psycho.

Diosoth
05-05-2009, 06:17 AM
DC Direct has started selling their toys through Toys R Us at prices cheaper than comic stores charge. About $3 cheaper. I wonder how many people will support the small guys VS saving money with this in place?

namzep
05-06-2009, 03:11 PM
I think the local collectable stores here have been closed for awhile. All we really seem to have anymore is Walmart, which sucks. I mostly just buy all sorts of collectables/toys online.